Perhaps you’ve been a real estate investor for decades and you’re working within an older corporate structure. Or maybe you’re a newer investor and want to learn what kind of corporation makes the most sense for your business. Or maybe you don’t have any interest in setting up any kind of formal corporate structure and want to do business under your own name. Whatever your unique situation might be, the kind of corporation you set up – or don’t set up – will have a huge impact on how much money you end up sticking in your bank account at the end of the day.
Recently a couple of successful real estate professionals, one a seasoned transactional real estate attorney and the other a very successful real estate investor, put their heads together and discussed the pros and cons of various corporate structures specifically for the real estate investing business. It turns out the best corporate entity varies depending on what you want to accomplish with your business. Here are a few corporate options to consider.
-Limited Liability Corporations (LLC)
An LLC is a legal entity that provides the same limited liability as a corporation with the tax benefits of a partnership. Many investors like working within LLCs for some very good reasons:
1. Liability protection – The LLC gives the owner personal liability protection. For example, in most states if you form an LLC and run it as a separate business concern you’re afforded the protection of a C Corporation. Meaning the owner/investor is going to be protected from any claim or personal liability that results from the day to day running of the business, and any business conducted or transactions performed on behalf of that company.
2. Tax benefits and streamlined operation – LLCs provide the legal protections of corporations but are taxed as though they were sole proprietorships. Another advantage of LLCs is they provide you with a lot of flexibility in operating your company. The laws for LLCs are newer, whereas C Corporations often deal with archaic business models that were being used in the 50′s or even earlier.
3. An LLC will give you the flexibility to structure your company similar to a partnership, but give you the liability protection. And by working with an accountant you can realize a lot of tax benefits.
4. Flexibility – The LLC gives you the freedom to run your company as though you were running it personally as an individual, but it gives you liability protection.
C Corporations (C Corps)
The C Corporation is the corporate structure most commonly used, especially by larger companies. However, these days many real estate pros consider the C Corp an unsatisfactory corporate entity for a real estate investment company for a number of reasons, although there are some positives as well. Here are some pros and cons:
1. Double Taxation – With C Corporations you are paying taxes twice. C Corps are taxed separately from the company’s owners, as opposed to an S Corporation which typically isn’t separately taxed. After the C Corp is taxed, any money that then goes out to shareholders, either as a dividend or a draw, must be claimed as income by the shareholder and is taxed as such. So essentially the owners are paying a tax twice.
2. Old stockholder laws – In a C Corporation, the owners are considered stockholders. Shares of stock are issued to the owners when the corporation is formed. When you deal with this kind of stock there are a lot of old laws to which you must adhere.
3. Issues when selling property – If you hold property for a long time in a C Corporation, like a rental property, it may be harder to sell than if it’s in another kind of entity.
4. Lots of paperwork – Usually there are annual corporate filing requirements which vary by state. Sometimes these can be a paperwork headache without professional help.
5. Reinvestment advantage – While the double taxation issue noted above is a drawback, a C Corporation provides the ability to reinvest profits in the business at a lower tax rate.
S Corporations (S Corps)
S Corporations are standard corporations which elect, for tax purposes, to pass income and losses through to its shareholders. S Corps combine the legal setup of a C Corp with a tax structure similar to a partnership.
1. Tax benefits – The income, tax credits, and deductions of an S Corp pass through to shareholders on an annual basis. Meaning income is taxed at the shareholder level instead of the corporate level. The IRS treats the S Corp as a pass-through entity. So you have the S Corp election, and income that is earned by the corporation passes through to the shareholders directly, thus taking out one of the taxes that occur with a C Corp.
2. Officer’s salaries dilute corporate income – In an S Corp, the officers have to take a salary, so they get a W-2 every year. Anything the owners take as a salary is going to dilute from the net income on the profit and loss statement, which reduces the amount of income for the business to be taxed. You’re paying an employment tax. You want your salary to be consistent with 40 to 50% of what the business is earning. If you do that, you can avoid that self-employment tax.
3. K-1 and W-2 forms – The owners of an S Corp get a K-1 form which reveals profit and loss for their share of the business. They also get a W-2 it they’re taking a salary. The K-1 is for the profits and W-2 for the salary. A K-1 form is issued when the S Corp has more than one member. If you’re a single member you can file a C-1 to your 1040. A K-1 is distributed when there are partners. The salaries are deducted from the net income of the business before the K-1 is issued, so the tax liability of the K-1 is reduced by the salaries paid to the owners.
A sole ownership, also called a sole proprietorship, is a business owned by one person. In this type of setup there is no legal distinction between the business and the owner. The owner controls all the assets, but is legally responsible for all debts and other liabilities.
1. Owner has total control – The owner gets all the profits from the business (less any taxes owed) and has total control of the business, including the responsibility for any debts and losses.
2. Difficult to raise private capital – When it comes to raising private money to fund your business, the government – whether it’s the federal SEC or your state SEC – wants you to raise money via a corporation rather than as a sole ownership-d/b/a. So the federal SEC and the state securities offices, when they issue rulings regarding in-trust state offerings and federal offerings, don’t want you to raise money in your own name. They want you to raise money through a legally established corporation. Meaning all your registrations – whether it’s notice filings, a state offering where your state wants to be advised that you’re raising money in that state or doing business in that state, on an intra-state offering or the federal SEC on a federal filing – need to be done under a corporation. You have to establish an LLC or a corporation within which you raise money.
3. Difficult to buy property – For the same reasons The federal SEC and state SECs want you to buy property through a legally recognized corporation and not through a d/b/a or sole ownership. They know that buying and selling property is your business, and should operate under the structure of a corporation.
Deciding on which type of corporate entity to use for your real estate investing company is one of the most important business decisions you can make, so it’s a good idea to consider your options very carefully. The consensus of the two real estate professionals noted above seemed to favor the LLC, but you should make up your own mind after careful consideration of your goals.
Strategic Real Estate Coach is led by Josh Cantwell. Josh is a full time real estate investor from Cleveland, Ohio who’s personally been involved in hundreds of profitable real estate transactions. He’s also been a mentor to students who’ve closed thousands of wholesaling, rehabs, rentals, foreclosure, pre-foreclosure and short sale transactions over the past 8 years. Josh has been training and teaching apprentice partners and students since 2004. Josh has vast knowledge and experience in helping coaching clients, mentor students and apprentice partners from across the US in finding, structuring, negotiating and closing various types of transactions for a profit.